
I think I may be alone in the opinions I'm about to express amongst our male-dominated class, but I don't care. If I like something it's important that I'm open about it. So, yes, I
will write a positive review about
High School Musical 3: Senior Year!
This is the first to play in cinemas, and I have to say that I was nervous about sitting in one of the many sold-out screenings with hundreds of children and teenagers! But similarly to when I saw
The Rocky Horror Show, being in with the crazed fans improved the experience. And, just like Rocky Horror, there was audience-participation. People clapped-along, cheered, wolf-whistled, and sang. It didn't ruin the experience - it added to it!
It's also the first of the films to actually feature a high school musical. In doing so they could feature truly theatrical songs and actually cut to the stage-musical which the film was building towards without taking itself too seriously. The songs themselves were good. Different enough from the previous films to feel fresh, but not so different as to sound like they belong elsewhere. One thing that struck me in this one was the struggle to
start songs. On a few occasions it felt awkward when someone, mid-conversation, bursted into song.

Most musicals struggle in getting the audience to suspend their disbelief. In real life people don't burst into spontaneous musical numbers. I'd argue that that's more a problem with reality than musicals. But when you see a film like this you surrender your right to complain about that. And because the audience accept it, musicals can often do other unrealistic things. With HSM3, though, I felt that they abused this right when the roof of a treehouse magically opened up during a song for no reason! Poetic, yes, but it brings you out of it! They made up for this, however, when two characters rolled under a car and came out the other side as themselves, aged-7, and carried on the song - dancing and all. It was brilliant and hilarious. Those are the sort of shenanigans that you can only pull in a musical!
But it's not
just a camp, light-hearted musical. There are serious issues about leaving high school, choosing a college, peer pressure, and - to some extent - relationships at a young age. Though, as expected, it does Disney-up high schools; no drinking, smoking, drugs, sex, teenage-pregnancies, etc. But surely we want kids to retain their innocence as long as possible!
I think that the main cast are really talented, and it's good to see long-serving supporting-characters rewarded too. I've read some reviews which criticise the film for under-using Lucas Grabeel's character, Ryan. Personally I disagree. They remained faithful to his character, and allowed the audience to see how his confidence has grown since the second one. Yes, character development! I think that's more important than screentime, even if he is a good actor.
The main reason that I like this film, however, is that it remains true to its roots. What made the first so good was that it was just a small, made-for-TV musical which nobody expected to do well. In that sense, it deserved all the attention it got. There wasn't a huge marketing campaign to begin with and it doesn't
feel commercially driven. It has a unique quality that is hard to describe, but resulted in this huge phenomenon. This quality it present in HSM3 too - probably because it's the same people making it, just with a bigger budget. But I'd still argue that the film's
plot is not commercially driven. The fact that it was
made was, but the film itself is a loyal continuation of the series. We live in a world of franchises now, sadly, but I think that this one deserves everything it got because it was made by people who loved what they were making. You can always tell, and it's worth a lot more than production values! And when you couple the two, you end up with something huge.
Okay, next post will be short. I promise.